MLB The Show 25: Building the Ultimate God Squad in a Switch-Hitter Dominated Meta

Every year, MLB The Show players chase the same dream: crafting the perfect God Squad. The final roster. The ultimate lineup. The team that turns Ranked Seasons into a personal highlight reel. And in MLB The Show 25, that chase feels more chaotic—and more meta-warping—than ever.

This year’s card pool has created a dramatic shift in how elite lineups look. No matter how much some players may hate it, switch hitters dominate the battlefield, and their insane attribute combinations make them nearly impossible to bench. Even players who normally love mixing pure right-handed mashers with lefty specialists have found themselves bending the knee to the switch-hitting meta.

But if you’re looking to build the absolute strongest roster possible—no restrictions, no theme-team limitations, no personal preferences—this is what it looks like. And yes, it's packed with “switchies,” as disgusting as that may feel to some purists.

Welcome to the definitive MLB 25 Stubs God Squad Breakdown.

The Centerpiece of the Offense: The Star-Studded Lineup

Even with dozens of elite cards dropping throughout the year, a handful rise above the rest. What becomes crystal clear in 25 is that the upper echelon of players all seem to have one thing in common: 125 contact and 125 power almost everywhere. Add 99 speed, diamond defense, and switch-handed flexibility, and you get an offensive meta that is as explosive as it is repetitive.

Still, building the best team means leaving your personal feelings at the door.

Ellie De La Cruz – The Apex Predator at Shortstop

Ellie is the first name written on the lineup card. With 125s across the board, freakish speed, rangy defense, and the coveted switch-hitting profile, he’s the most unfair shortstop in the game. Whether he's launching apple-taco bombs or making impossible diving plays, Ellie is the engine of the God Squad.

Michael (Trout or Harris III, depending on the card) – The GOAT in Center

Every version of Michael—yes, that Michael—has always been a fixture in elite lineups, but this year’s top card is incredible even by MLB Show standards. Perfect swing animation, nonstop extra-base potential, and elite fielding make him a staple. He starts, he stars, he carries.

Chipper Jones – 125s and Switch-Hitting Perfection

Chipper returns to his familiar perch near the heart of the order. Even in a game overflowing with cartoonish offensive stats, this version of Chipper somehow stands out. His swing feels like it was handcrafted by the baseball gods themselves.

“Big Daddy” Vlad Guerrero Sr. – The Best Righty in the Game?

A controversial pick? Maybe to some. But Vlad Sr.’s card is pure bliss for right-handed hitters. Many players have forgotten just how smooth his swing feels. Others simply can’t believe that a non-switch hitter can still hang in the meta.

But this version of Vlad?

He doesn't just “hang.”

He dominates.

Paralleled high enough, he approaches full 125s everywhere. Comfortable at-bats, elite power, laser-beam line drives—Vlad Sr. earns his spot.

Lou Gehrig – The Unquestioned King of First Base

Every year has its “best first baseman” debate, but this year, it's not a debate. Lou Gehrig is the best. Unreal swing, elite attributes, and consistent performance across hundreds of at-bats make him irreplaceable.

Ketel Marte – The Second-Base Menace

If you’re sweating for a win, Ketel is on your team. If you want optimal offense, he’s on your team. If you're trying to avoid switchies… well, tough luck—he’s still on your team.

Marte is the perfect second baseman in The Show 25:

Switch hitter

Elite contact

Top-tier defense

Dangerous power

Excellent swing plane

He’s disgusting. He’s meta. And he’s unavoidable.

The Dumper – The Best Catcher in the Game

When a switch-hitting catcher brings 125s to the party, you stop asking questions. You start writing him into your lineup permanently.

Dumpy’s combination of pop, contact, and plate coverage makes him the most infuriating out in the game. And with countless monster home runs—and at least one poor fan taking a Dumper missile off the forehead—he’s become a legend.

“Little Daddy” Vlad Jr. – A 125 Machine

Another Guerrero, another ridiculous card. Vlad Jr. hits everything. Literally everything. You could pitch him a bowling ball and he'd still lace it down the line for a double-double-double.

With full parallel levels, he becomes 125 across all major offensive categories. Not a switch-hitter, but he might as well be based on results.

Ian Happ – The Ultimate Boosted Destroyer

Happ doesn’t just hit well—he hits everything well. Fully boosted, he sits on maxed-out attributes, offering left-field versatility and nonstop slugging. He might not get the headlines, but he’s an absolute menace in any lineup.

The Bench: Power, Speed & Situational Weapons

No God Squad is complete without the right mix of bench talent. For 25, the best supplementary group looks like this:

Trea Turner – Speed demon and elite pinch runner

Juan Soto – Pure lefty power for late-game nukes

Kyle Schwarber – The king of pinch-hit home runs

Byron Buxton – Insert him and lefties disappear instantly

(Occasional) Brent Rooker Replacement – Because… why was he even there?

This bench gives you every tool:

A righty masher

A lefty masher

A contact boost

A defensive substitution

A base-stealing nightmare

Perfectly balanced—just like a God Squad should be.

Starting Rotation: The Absolute Filth Factory

Pitching wins championships, and the God Squad rotation is full of nightmares.

John Donaldson – Pure Toxic

John Donaldson is downright rude. His stuff is nasty. His pace is demonic. And when he's locating? Forget about it. He defines the meta from the mound.

Jacob deGrom – Back Again With the Best Stuff in the Game

Every year, deGrom terrorizes hitters. This year, he's somehow worse (better?). His velocity and break combo make him a miserable experience for anyone unlucky enough to face him.

Paul Skenes – Boosting Your Finest Squad

Skenes isn’t always dominant statistically, but he provides crucial Finest boosts for themed rosters. His pitch mix is solid, and when boosted, he fits right in with elite arms.

Roger Clemens – Maxed Per Nines and Lunatic Velocity

Nearly perfect per-nines combined with cartoon velocity make Clemens one of the most annoying pitchers in the entire game. He throws 165 MPH sinkers in the ninth inning with 90% stamina. It's madness.

Shohei Ohtani – The Most Infuriating Opponent

Facing Ohtani should count as a war crime. His combo of velocity, movement, and deception is unmatched. Many players refuse to face him ever again—and that alone earns him a rotation spot.

The Bullpen: Chaos, Cheese & Two-Seam Abominations

No bullpen will please everyone, but this one has all the tools needed to lock down any game.

Aroldis Chapman

Annoying to face. Terrifying on paper. But some players get shelled with him for reasons unknown. Still, he's too good not to include.

Andrew Miller

The best lefty in the game—no question. His sweeping slider is unfair.

Troy Melton

Ridiculous delivery. Pure irritation. Auto-include.

Andrés Muñoz

Could be swapped, but his maxed per nines and high velocity give him a place.

Garrett Whitlock

Underrated. Nasty pitch mix. Hard to time up.

Josh Hader

A secret weapon that somehow remains unpatched:

His two-seam fastball is broken.

If you're not using him, you’re handicapping yourself.

Darren O’Day

Interesting choice. Maybe for memes. Maybe for trolls. Maybe for chaos. Not the strongest card but certainly unique.

Félix Bautista & Waldrip

Two elite endgame options who’ll anchor any bullpen deep into the season.

Gameplay: The God Squad in Action

Once the God Squad takes the field, the stats come alive:

Ellie's apple-taco bombs

Michael's no-doubt moonshots

Dumpy’s stadium-destroying missiles

Vlad Sr. peppering doubles like a machine

Marte smashing lefties and righties alike

Even with early-game struggles or PCI shrinkage, the lineup finds ways to explode. And when the pitching locks in, mercy rules pile up quickly, cheap MLB The Show 25 Stubs.

Multiple outings highlight the squad’s strengths:

A 16–4 mercy rule win

A 14–1 demolition

Explosive multi-homer innings

Pure fundamental hitting—punching balls the other way and up the middle

Even when the player claims he's old and washed, the God Squad proves itself unstoppable.

The Final Verdict: MLB The Show 25’s Ultimate Lineup

Whether you love or hate the switch-hitter meta, it defines MLB The Show 25. The best cards are overloaded, flexible, and insanely fun to hit with—even if the lack of handedness variety can feel repetitive.

But if you're chasing greatness—true endgame dominance—this is what the God Squad looks like:

Ellie

Michael

Chipper

Big Daddy Vlad

Lou

Dumpy

Little Daddy Vlad

Marte Parte

Ian Happ

Supported by a bench of monsters and a pitching staff full of nightmares.

It may be gross. It may be cheesy. It may be swamped with switch-hitters.

But it is undeniably the strongest team you can build in MLB The Show 25.

And after all—when you’re hitting nukes, mercy-ruling opponents, and watching Dumpy ruin a fan’s hot dog—who’s complaining?